More heartbreak for Proteas as Australia crush World Cup dreams

Proteas captain Temba Bavuma reacts after failing to run out Australia's Mitchell Starc in the ICC Cricket World Cup semifinal at Eden Gardens in Kolkata, India on Thursday.
Proteas captain Temba Bavuma reacts after failing to run out Australia's Mitchell Starc in the ICC Cricket World Cup semifinal at Eden Gardens in Kolkata, India on Thursday.
Image: Reuters/Andrew Boyers

There is no solace in defeat. South Africa didn’t stop trying here in Kolkata, but they just never had enough of their best game or runs on the board or chances taken or even, yes, luck. 

Australia were simply the better team on the Eden Gardens field in Thursday's 2023 ICC Cricket World Cup semifinal. They certainly out-bowled and out-fielded the Proteas. They were more assertive at the start of their innings compared to South Africa, but they were allowed to be because the Proteas weren’t as precise with the new ball as Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc had been. 

That opening, after Temba Bavuma had won the toss and chose to do the thing his side is most comfortable with, and bat, was ultimately where this match was lost. There can be no coming back from 24/4 after 12 overs, even with David Miller producing a magnificent hundred (101) and the partnerships he forged that took South Africa past 200. 

The Proteas kept scrapping, just to hang in there and to give themselves a chance, but Australia have always been a side that, once ahead, will not allow themselves to get caught.

South Africa's 212 — all out with two balls to spare — would always be below par. They fought in the bowling and plugged away, making for tense moments, but ultimately Australia could knock off 215/7 with breathing room in 47.2overs. 

In the aftermath, questions will be asked about Bavuma’s decision at the toss. It was the right one; Pat Cummins, would have batted too. It’s what suits his team, it’s just that Hazlewood in particular was magnificent.

Presented with conditions, more akin to Headingley — albeit with barmier temperatures — Hazlewood snapped, crackled and popped. There was the early blow of Bavuma’s dismissal four nought to Starc that immediately raised Australian confidence. 

It was a tentative four-ball stay at the crease by the South African captain who admitted on Wednesday he wasn’t 100% fit. Questions about his selection will undoubtedly form part of the post-tournament debrief and at the very least a debate needs to be had about the establishment of fitness policy.

In Bavuma’s defence, the delivery from Starc would have probably dismissed him even if he had been completely fit.

Australia’s fielding was aggressive and suffocating, aiding in creating the pressure that led to the ill-judged and poorly-executed strokes from Quinton de Kock, Rassie van der Dussen and Aiden Markram. 

Miller’s sublime innings salvaged the contest. Having never played a Test match, here he produced an innings that wouldn’t have been out of place in one. He weathered the storm from Hazlewood and showed due care against the Australian off-spinners. It was against the leg-spin of Adam Zampa that he sought to give South Africa a foothold. 

However, as excellent as that knock was, because of the modest returns of the top four Miller’s innings only provided a flicker of hope. 

David Warner and Travis Head tried to douse those aspirations in the first power play with a calculated assault against Kagiso Rabada and the wayward Marco Jansen, that saw them raise fifty on the scoreboard in the sixth over.

Warner’s wicket changed the tone of the innings. Bowled by Markram, who let out a ferocious roar as the stumps lit up, South Africa cracked open the window.

Suddenly they began to create chances; Head was missed twice, by substitute fielder Reeza Hendricks and then Heinrich Klaasen. De Kock missed a devilishly difficult opportunity offered by Steve Smith off Tabraiz Shamsi.

But Shamsi and Keshav Maharaj turned the screws on the Australians. Suddenly they looked nervous and when they tried to attack Marnus Labuschagne and Glenn Maxwell were dismissed.

It turned into a dirty struggle — trench warfare on a cricket field — Smith barely looked for the boundary, until he did and skied Coetzee with De Kock taking a fine catch as the ball dropped from the heavens. 

It was the 23-year-old with that wicket, and then the dismissal of Josh Inglis as part of a courageous eight over spell, who raised South Africa’s hopes. But there weren’t enough runs any more. There weren’t the same tears as in Auckland, nor quite the anguish of Birmingham, but there will be regret. 

Australia fly to Ahmedabad where India await in Sunday’s final. South Africa head home, heartbroken once again.