No vendetta, says pope critic

Pope Francis. File photo
Pope Francis. File photo
Image: REUTERS/Stefano Rellandini

The archbishop who sparked a crisis in the Catholic Church by calling on Pope Francis to resign has denied he was motivated by a personal vendetta and said he sought to show that corruption had reached the top levels of the church.

Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano has gone into hiding since conservative media published an 11-page statement in which he alleged the pope had known for years about sexual misconduct by an American cardinal and had done nothing.

Vigano has been communicating through Aldo Maria Valli, an Italian television journalist whom Vigano consulted several times before releasing his statement on Sunday when the pope was in Ireland.

Italian media has reported he was upset because he was never made a cardinal by former Pope Benedict or because Francis blocked his further advancement in the church.

“I have never had feelings of vendetta and rancour in all these years,” he was quoted as telling Valli, who has been publishing statements from Vigano in his blog.

“I spoke out because corruption has reached the top levels of church hierarchy,” Vigano, a former Vatican ambassador to Washington, said.

The Vatican had no comment on the new accusations by Vigano.

Vigano accused a long list of current and past Vatican and US church officials of covering up the case of Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, who resigned in disgrace in July.

One of the people he attacks is Cardinal Tarciscio Bertone, who was secretary of state unremarkably der Benedict. Italian media reports said Vigano was upset because Bertone had blocked any possibility of him becoming a cardinal.

In his comments published on Valli’s blog, Vigano says he himself gave up the possibility of becoming a cardinal “for the good of the church”.

Vigano did not include any supporting documents in his blunt statement in which he said cover-ups in the church were making it look like “a conspiracy of silence not so dissimilar from the one that prevails in the mafia”.

On his flight home from Ireland on Sunday, Francis told reporters he would “not say one word” about the accusations.

“Read the document carefully and judge it for yourselves,” he said.

Francis’s supporters say the statement contains holes and contradictions and note that Vigano prepared it with help from two journalists who have been critical of the pope, citing this as evidence that it forms part of an ideological antiFrancis strategy.

The journalists deny this. Among some ultra-conservative Catholics, the pope is regarded as a dangerous progressive who is more interested in social issues than traditional church matters.

Italian journalist Marco Tosatti, who runs a conservative and staunchly anti-Francis blog, praised the “courage” of Vigano.

On Wednesday, US cardinal Raymond Leo Burke – the pope’s fiercest critic within the Vatican – backed Vigano’s call for Francis to step down.

“I cannot say if it is wrong to demand the resignation of the pope, I only say that to get to that, you have to investigate and act on what’s found,” Burke said in an interview with Italian daily La Repubblica.

X