SA's auto industry ambitions under huge threat from coronavirus

A worker checks the body shell of a BMW X3 on the production line at the BMW Rosslyn plant in Midrand, South Africa.
A worker checks the body shell of a BMW X3 on the production line at the BMW Rosslyn plant in Midrand, South Africa.
Image: Stefan Kleinowitz/Bloomberg via Getty Images

The expansion of SA's auto industry is central to the government's economic development strategy but the coronavirus crisis has forced car makers into survival mode and could push ambitious growth plans out of reach.

Industry officials say the government needs to defer some tax payments for the auto industry and relax the criteria for investment incentives and allowances, or the pandemic could deal the sector a permanent blow.

Before the crisis, the government had crafted a plan to supercharge the sector to help revive the country's struggling economy and form a beachhead for expansion within Africa, the world's last major untapped market for new cars.

But a five-week lockdown has brought a manufacturing and retail industry that accounts for almost 7% of SA's GDP and 30% of its manufacturing output to a virtual standstill.

“Those plans will be impacted massively,” said Mike Mabasa, CEO of the National Association of Automobile Manufacturers of SA (Naamsa). “Particularly for the short to medium term, that plan is completely out of the window.”

SA has put its so-called automotive master plan at the heart of attempts to revive growth through industrialisation after years of stagnation and to bring unemployment down from almost 30%.

The plan aims to boost growth and create jobs by more than doubling the industry's annual production to 1.4 million vehicles by 2035 and raising the proportion of auto components made locally to 60% from 39%.

The new scheme comes after a series of auto industry development plans and will be supported by investment and tax incentives that have been in place in some form for years.

They include a tax-free cash grant starting at 20% of the value of qualifying investments, rising to 25% for component makers, and a tax perk related to vehicle production, known as the vehicle assembly allowance.

Scant response 

Mabasa said Naamsa has asked the government to relax the minimum plant production capacity threshold of 50,000 cars a year needed for the investment incentive as car makers believe it's too stringent given the fallout from the crisis.

As part of a series of requests on behalf of the industry, Naamsa has also asked the government to use 2019 production numbers and targets for 2020's vehicle assembly allowance, as output is likely to take a major hit this year.

The sector had some relief with the easing of the country's lockdown on May 1 as it allowed auto manufacturers to return to 50% capacity. But it has had scant response from the government to its calls for specific financial help, besides requests for more information.

The department of trade & industry did not respond to requests for comment.

Most of SA's car makers referred Reuters to Naamsa for comment.

Naamsa represents 41 firms — including BMW, Ford, Mercedes-Benz, Isuzu, Nissan, Toyota and Volkswagen — which make some 600,000 vehicles a year in SA and export about 65% of them.

Mercedes-Benz South Africa said it was not possible to predict the impact of Covid-19 on the 2035 industry targets.

“We have constructive relationships with our key stakeholders in suppliers and the government, and are confident that we will be able to find solutions to maintain the competitiveness of the automotive manufacturing sector,” its corporate affairs manager, Thato Mntambo, told Reuters.

Small firms vulnerable

Naamsa's Mabasa warned that if car makers struggle for liquidity in the crisis they may be unable to fulfil export orders, worth $9bn (roughly R166.1bn) a year across the industry. Local component makers focused on cars could also suffer badly.

Industry officials said the damage could be permanent and open the way for upcoming rivals such as Morocco and more established centres like Thailand to steal market share.

Andrew Kirby, CEO of Toyota South Africa, said last month that the risk to the country's role in global auto industry supply chains stemmed mostly from the vulnerability of its smaller component manufacturers.

If either vehicle makers or parts manufacturers cannot deliver their products, international customers will rapidly take their business elsewhere, industry officials said.

Renai Moothilal, executive director of the National Association of Automotive Component and Allied Manufacturers, said there was a strong possibility smaller firms would not survive and that would be disastrous for the government's drive to boost local output and double employment in the sector.

He said levers the government could pull included levy waivers and support for utility and wage bills, but without help it was not hard to see how an industry that has already lost much of its business case might contract rather than expand.

“Once global companies move export contracts, and invest in tools of production in another destination, the costs sunk into that move make it improbable that they would want to bring it back to SA,” Moothilal said.

The final bar in each chart shows the IHS Markit forecast for 2020 sales. Domestic new cars sales in South Africa alone are expected to fall by 20%, but local car makers will also be hit by the decline in global demand. Data and forecasts supplied by IHS Markit and cover vehicles weighing up to six tons.
The final bar in each chart shows the IHS Markit forecast for 2020 sales. Domestic new cars sales in South Africa alone are expected to fall by 20%, but local car makers will also be hit by the decline in global demand. Data and forecasts supplied by IHS Markit and cover vehicles weighing up to six tons.
Image: Emma Rumney | REUTERS GRAPHICS

Hitting the reset button

Naamsa's Mabasa said the overseas headquarters of some local component manufacturers had already indicated they could shift production to divisions outside SA.

About 90% of the business of one local supplier, SP Metal Forgings (SPF), is in the automotive sector. CEO Ken Manners said the initial three-week lockdown alone had probably cost it 12% to 15% of annual turnover.

Another local component supplier, Pressure Die Castings (PDC), said it was expecting to lose 15% of its turnover for at least three months from the start of the lockdown.

“If we were only in (auto) manufacturing, we probably would have closed the company,” said Graham Smith, MD of PDC, which supplies components to several industries.

The car sector will benefit from some economywide tax measures already announced, such as deferred payments on a carbon tax, but the demands on SA's strained public finances are huge, with many key industries in trouble.

With the country's debt rating now firmly in junk territory and an economic contraction inevitable, there are questions over how it will even pay for measures already announced.

Meanwhile, the risk of a return to a more expansive lockdown looms and demand for vehicles at home and abroad has plummeted.

IHS Markit senior analyst Walt Madeira said car production will fall too. It forecasts global light vehicle sales will drop to 69.6 million units this year from 89.7 million in 2019, with a 20% decline in SA.

And any change of tack by car makers at the top of the production pyramid will ripple through the industry.

“It's like pushing a big reset button and nobody is quite sure what that means,” SPF's Manners said. “It's very worrying in terms of what our businesses are going to look like in six months.”


Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments? Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.

X